Auto Loan Rejections on the Rise: What Borrowers Should Know and How to Improve Your Chances

Getting turned down for a car loan is becoming more common, a worrying trend for many prospective car buyers. According to data referenced by CNBC Select, auto loan rejection rates are climbing, leaving many would-be buyers unsure how to secure financing. Rising interest rates, tighter lending standards, and financial stress among consumers have all combined to make auto lending more difficult. 

This article explores why rejections are increasing, what lenders are looking for, and actionable strategies borrowers can use to improve their odds of approval.

Why Are Auto Loan Rejections Rising?

Elevated Credit Risk & Tighter Lending Standards

Lenders today are more cautious than before. As borrowing costs go up, banks and finance companies are raising their underwriting standards. According to industry reports, many lenders are increasingly wary of approving loans to subprime borrowers, fearing delinquencies and defaults.

Higher interest rates imposed by the Federal Reserve have also made auto loans more expensive for both lenders and borrowers. In this environment, less creditworthy borrowers may be pushed out or rejected entirely.

Consumer Anxiety & Discouraged Borrowers

Consumer sentiment is also shifting. The New York Fed’s Survey of Consumer Expectations shows a rising percentage of people believe their auto-loan application will be rejected. In fact, 33.5% of respondents expected a denial, the highest level seen in 15 years. 

This rising anxiety may itself be part of the problem: some potential borrowers may not even apply, or apply less aggressively, because they assume they'll be declined.

High Rejection Rates in Practice

Actual rejection numbers back up these concerns. According to Nasdaq, auto loan applications are being denied at rates as high as 14.2%, up significantly from prior data. 

And a Kelley Blue Book write-up based on Fed data confirms more than 14% of applicants are being turned away, a record high.

The Impact of Rising Loan Rejections

Rejections aren't just a hiccup for car buyers. They ripple out through the broader economy and affect individuals’ financial health.

• Consumer Confidence: When many expect rejection, fewer apply, meaning potential car sales are lost even before the application stage. DecisioningIT reports that part of the surge in loan rejections is driven by this "discouraged borrower" effect.
   
• Dealership Sales: Lower credit approval rates mean car dealerships may lose more sales, especially for customers relying on financing.
   
• Credit Healing Risk: As more applications are denied, consumers may turn to riskier financing options, stretch their budgets, or delay purchases, any of which could increase long-term financial stress.

What Makes a Strong Auto Loan Application?

To reduce the risk of rejection, here’s what lenders typically examine and how borrowers can strengthen their profile.

1. Credit Score & History

A key factor is your credit score. Many traditional lenders look for a FICO score of 670 or higher, though there are more flexible lenders that may work with lower scores. To improve your score:

• Pay off revolving balances consistently.
   
• Avoid opening too many new credit accounts at once.
   
• Review your credit reports for inaccuracies and dispute any errors.

2. Debt-to-Income (DTI) Ratio

Lenders want to see that you have enough income to handle additional monthly payments. A high DTI (i.e., a lot of your income is already going to debt) is a red flag. Try to reduce other debts (credit cards, personal loans) before applying.

3. Down Payment

Putting more money down can make a big difference:

• Increases the likelihood of approval by reducing the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio.
   
• Lowers monthly payments. According to CNBC Select, each additional $1,000 in down payment reduces the monthly payment by roughly $20, assuming a rate around 5%.

4. Co-Signer

If your credit score or income is weak, a co-signer with a strong financial profile can significantly improve your chances. Lenders consider the co-signer’s credit history and ability to repay, which can offset risk.

5. Choose the Right Lender

Not all lenders are the same. Here are a few strategies for picking where to apply:

• Credit unions often have more competitive rates and may be more flexible than big banks.
   
• Specialised auto-loan marketplaces (like MyAutoLoan) let you compare multiple offers and find lenders who are more willing to work with lower FICO scores.
   
• Prequalification tools: Try using a lender’s preapproval or prequalification process. Soft credit checks (which don’t hurt your score) can give you an idea of whether you’ll be approved without fully applying.

Example: How Application Choices Affect Approval Odds

Here’s a table illustrating how different borrower profiles and strategies may influence the likelihood of securing an auto loan:

Summary: By tailoring your approach, choosing the right lender, improving your credit or down payment, or using a co-signer, you can significantly increase your odds, even in a tighter credit environment.

Preparing for Rejection — and What to Do After?

Even with strong preparation, rejection is possible. Here’s how to handle it:

1. Ask for a Denial Reason: When a loan is denied, request specific feedback. Some lenders may point to credit score, DTI, or income — understanding the reason helps you address it.
    
2. Reassess & Reapply Later: Use the denial as feedback. Improve your financial profile (reduce debt, save more for a down payment) and reapply after six to twelve months.
    
3. Build Credit Wisely: Consider paying down credit cards, or taking a small secured loan, and pay on time to boost your creditworthiness.
    
4. Consider Alternative Financing: Credit unions, buy-here-pay-here dealerships, or peer-to-peer financing may be more flexible, though sometimes costlier. Be sure to read the terms carefully.
    
5. Negotiate with the Dealer: Sometimes, having preapproval (even partial) gives you leverage to negotiate price, trade-in, or rate terms with the dealer.

Conclusion

Auto loan rejection rates are indeed rising, driven by tighter lending standards, elevated interest rates, and growing consumer insecurity. But getting turned down doesn’t have to be the end of the road. By understanding what lenders prioritize — your credit score, income, debt load, and down payment — and using smart strategies like co-signers or prequalification, you can greatly improve your chances of being approved.

In a more cautious credit environment, preparation, patience, and financial discipline are your strongest tools. Rather than rushing in, build your profile, choose your lender wisely, and apply when you’re in the strongest position to succeed.
 

Apply for Loans Fast and Hassle-Free

Apply Now

About the Author

LoansJagat Team

‘Simplify Finance for Everyone.’ This is the common goal of our team, as we try to explain any topic with relatable examples. From personal to business finance, managing EMIs to becoming debt-free, we do extensive research on each and every parameter, so you don’t have to. Scroll up and have a look at what 15+ years of experience in the BFSI sector looks like.