Difference Between VAT And GST: What Sets Them Apart?

Key Takeaways

• VAT and GST are both indirect taxes. Indirect taxes are those taxes which are charged on services and goods and do not apply to profits and income. 
   
• Value Added Tax is the full form of VAT; as its name highlights, this tax is applicable at all stages of the supply chain, wherever value is added to the product. 
   
• Goods and Services Tax is the full form of GST; as its name highlights, this tax applies to both services and goods. This tax was introduced in India on July 1, 2017, replacing VAT, excise duty, and several other indirect taxes.

Indirect taxes form the backbone of how goods and services are priced in the market. Two major systems that shaped the taxation of goods and services are Value Added Tax (VAT) and Goods and Services Tax (GST).

Suppose a trader sells electronic goods worth ₹1,00,000. Under VAT at 12%, the price becomes ₹1,12,000. When the retailer sells the same goods again in another state, he pays VAT once more, which increases the cost further.

Under GST at 12%, the trader charges ₹1,12,000, but the retailer can claim input tax credit on what he paid earlier. The cascading effect (tax on tax at each stage) is reduced, and the tax system becomes more transparent.

Right now, some terms might confuse you, but do not worry, keep reading this blog, and you will understand everything. In this blog, we learn about VAT and GST, their differences, and why GST was introduced.

What Is VAT?

Value Added Tax (VAT) is applied as an indirect tax on goods sold. Tax was levied at each point in the supply chain when the value increased.

Since different states decided their own VAT rates, compliance became complex for businesses operating across multiple states.

Suppose a manufacturer sells furniture to a wholesaler at ₹50,000 with a VAT rate of 10%. The invoice becomes ₹55,000 (₹50,000 + ₹5,000 VAT). The wholesaler then supplies the goods to a retailer at ₹70,000.

VAT is applied again only on the margin of ₹20,000. So, VAT = ₹2,000, making the bill ₹72,000. This shows how VAT is applied at every stage of value addition. The following table highlights the features of VAT:
 

VAT worked well for a time but created complications for interstate trade and businesses dealing in multiple states, pushing policymakers to design a better system, which came in the form of GST.

Read More – Benefits of GST: Key Reasons Why GST is a Game Changer for India

What Is GST?

Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a unified tax introduced in 2017, which replaced VAT, service tax, excise duty, and many other indirect taxes. Unlike VAT, GST applies to both goods and services, making it more comprehensive.

Let’s take the same furniture case under GST. The manufacturer sells to a wholesaler for ₹50,000 at 18% GST = ₹59,000. The wholesaler then sells it for ₹70,000 plus GST of ₹12,600 = ₹82,600.

Here, the wholesaler can claim credit for the GST he paid earlier (₹9,000), so he only pays the difference of ₹3,600. This prevents double taxation and ensures transparency. The table here summarises the important features of GST:
 

From the above-mentioned table, we can analyse that GST addressed the shortcomings of VAT and built a more standardised tax regime.

Difference Between VAT And GST

Both VAT and GST served the same purpose of taxing consumption, but their structure and execution were quite different. 

VAT worked only on goods and created confusion due to state-specific rules. GST unified everything under one umbrella. The following table shows a comparison between VAT and GST:
 

The comparison in the table highlights how GST provides more transparency than VAT. VAT laid the foundation for indirect taxes, but GST streamlined the system, cutting down overlaps and simplifying compliance.

Bonus Tip: Under VAT, the seller’s state kept the tax revenue from inter-state sales, but GST changed this with IGST. Now, the consuming state receives the tax share, ensuring fair distribution and reducing disputes between states.

Also Read -What is Indirect Tax: Meaning, Types & Examples Explained

Why Was GST Introduced?

The government introduced GST to solve the challenges created by VAT and other indirect taxes; these multiple taxes were creating confusion among sellers and buyers. Also, businesses were facing higher costs because they could not set off taxes paid in one state against taxes paid in another.

Suppose Gautam is a textile dealer. Under VAT, he faces double taxation when selling goods across states, while under GST, the process becomes simpler and more transparent. 

This table illustrates the impact of VAT and GST on nylon purchases, offering a detailed view of how taxes are calculated at different stages:
 

The need to simplify taxation across states and avoid cascading was the prime reason GST replaced VAT.

Conclusion

VAT and GST both shaped how indirect taxes worked, but their impact differs. Unlike VAT, which taxes only goods differently in each state, GST unifies taxation across goods and services.

GST reduced cascading, made interstate trade simpler, and gave businesses and consumers more clarity about taxation. The move from VAT to GST marked a major reform, unifying various taxes and eliminating the cascading effect in India’s indirect tax system.

FAQs

1. What is the GST on rice?

Unbranded and loose rice is fully exempt from GST, while branded or packaged rice is taxed at 5%, reflecting the distinction between essential staples and value-added products.

2. How much is the GST on ice cream?

Ice cream is taxed at 18% GST, as it falls under the category of processed food items, making it more expensive compared to basic dairy products like milk or curd.

3. What is GST on milk?

Fresh milk attracts no GST, whereas flavoured, condensed, or packaged milk products are generally taxed at 5% or 12%, depending on their processing and value addition.

4. What is VAT on liquor?

Liquor is excluded from GST and taxed under VAT, with state governments setting their own slabs; rates generally range between 15% and 25%, based on policies and revenue needs.

5. Can we sell clothes on Amazon without GST?

GST registration is compulsory for selling clothes on Amazon, regardless of turnover, since e-commerce platforms require sellers to be GST-registered to list and supply their products.

6. Which product has the highest GST in India?

Luxury goods such as premium cars and tobacco fall under the highest GST slab of 28%, with an additional cess imposed to further increase the overall tax burden.

7. Which item has the lowest GST?

Essential goods such as salt, bread, fresh fruits, vegetables, curd, milk, and honey fall under the 0% GST slab, ensuring these daily-use items remain affordable for consumers.

Apply for Loans Fast and Hassle-Free

Apply Now

About the Author

LoansJagat Team

We are a team of writers, editors, and proofreaders with 15+ years of experience in the finance field. We are your personal finance gurus! But, we will explain everything in simplified language. Our aim is to make personal and business finance easier for you. While we help you upgrade your financial knowledge, why don't you read some of our blogs?