Disclaimer: The information published on LoansJagat is intended for general informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, or investment advice. Interest rates, loan terms, statistics, and other data may change over time and may vary by lender or source. Please verify the latest information and consult a qualified financial advisor or the respective Bank/NBFC before making any financial decisions.
Subscribe Now
About the author

Arshathul Afia is a journalism graduate and fintech content writer with 4+ years of experience in digital publishing and research-led writing. She has written 200+ articles covering personal finance, lending, banking, digital payments, credit, insurance, and major financial developments in India. At LoansJagat, she focuses on simplifying complex fintech news, RBI updates, loan-related changes, policy developments, and industry trends for everyday readers. Her journalism background helps her approach stories with research, context, and clarity, while her SEO experience ensures content remains discoverable and relevant. She aims to make financial news easier to understand, practical, and useful for readers across India.
Related News
Simplify All Your Loans Into One Affordable EMI
Customers Served
Debt Consolidated
1200+ Reviews
Locations in India
Club all Loans & Credit Card Bills into Single EMI
Quick Apply Loan
Consolidate your debts into one easy EMI.
Takes less than 2 minutes. No paperwork.
10 Lakhs+
Trusted Customers
2000 Cr+
Loans Disbursed
4.7/5
Google Reviews
50+
Banks & NBFCs Offers
The Supreme Court reaffirmed states’ pre-GST sales tax surcharge powers, retained the S. Kodar precedent and left individual tax disputes for regular Benches to decide.
Key Highlights
States could calculate additional sales tax or surcharge on the sales tax a dealer owed under the pre-GST regime, the Supreme Court reaffirmed on 4 November 2026. Chief Justice Surya Kant’s Bench found that the constitutional entry and state laws behind the dispute had since been substituted or replaced. It therefore treated the 27-year-old reference as academic.
Businesses’ liabilities for earlier assessment periods still require decisions from regular Benches. In Arjun Flour Mills v. The State of Odisha Finance Department Secretary & Ors., reported as 2026 INSC 1192, the Court retained the governing precedent and kept taxpayers’ rights to contest individual assessments and seek consequential relief open. The judgment did not resolve each tax demand.
For salaried employees, the distinction concerns the type of tax. The Supreme Court examined additional sales tax payable by dealers under earlier state laws. Salary taxation and personal borrowing belong to separate financial arrangements. The surcharge upheld in principle attaches to the dealer’s sales tax liability.
For taxpayers with an outstanding business-tax dispute, the judgment separates 2 questions: whether the state had power to impose the levy, and what the individual taxpayer owes. S. Kodar governs the first. Regular Benches will decide the second, including the remaining assessment and relief issues. A ruling on legislative power therefore does not, by itself, establish the amount recoverable in every case.
Read also: HDFC Bank’s Parivartan Links Kashmir Farmers to Buyers, Reports FPO Revenue of Up to ₹5.2 Crore
Rohit Jain, Managing Partner at Singhania & Co, said in remarks published on 4 November 2026 that the ruling reaffirmed additional sales tax as an increase in the sales tax rate. He explained that the judgment had limited relevance to the present GST regime and did not authorise a fresh surcharge outside existing GST laws.
Sachin Sharma, Managing Partner at KVT Tax Consultants, said states could rely on the decision to defend pending pre-GST levies. Individual assessments, however, would not become valid automatically. Questions involving exemptions, limitation, computation and refunds would require separate decisions. The Court’s directions send those disputes to regular Benches for disposal on their individual merits.
The dealers challenged a levy calculated on tax already payable. They argued that such a charge exceeded states’ sales tax powers. The states maintained that the surcharge merely increased the underlying tax.
Dealers whose gross turnover exceeded ₹10 lakh owed a surcharge of 10% of total tax payable under Section 5-A of the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947. Paragraph 7 of the judgment identifies 1 July 1990 as the date this provision took effect. The Court treated the calculation method and the character of the tax as separate questions.
The judgment retained the following positions.
Paragraphs 102–103 record these conclusions and directions. The Court treated a surcharge calculated as a percentage of sales tax as an increase in that tax’s rate.
The Supreme Court initially referred the issue to a larger Bench on 13 August 1998 after identifying an apparent conflict between earlier judgments. On 6 October 1999, a five-judge Bench subsequently referred the matter to a seven-judge Bench to reconsider the ruling in S. Kodar. The 1974 S. Kodar judgment had upheld additional sales tax, while Hoechst Pharmaceuticals upheld a sales tax surcharge in 1983.
The introduction of GST on 1 July 2017 was followed by another legal change in 2024: Mineral Area Development Authority v. Steel Authority of India overturned India Cement’s premise that royalty is a tax. The Supreme Court found no surviving conflict requiring reconsideration of S. Kodar. It reserved the present verdict on 22 September 2026.
The Supreme Court retained states’ pre-GST surcharge powers while preserving taxpayers’ individual objections. Justice K.V. Viswanathan’s separate opinion held that S. Kodar remained good law and required no reconsideration. The reference has ended; the connected appeals will proceed under the existing precedent.
The Court reaffirmed the governing precedent on states’ power to levy additional sales tax or surcharge under the pre-GST framework.
The Odisha provision examined in the judgment calculated surcharge on sales tax payable by the dealer. The Court retained its character as sales tax.
The decision concerns dealers’ historical sales tax liabilities. It does not revise salary tax deductions or contractual loan repayments.
No. The Court left individual assessments, levy periods and consequential relief for regular Benches to decide.
The Supreme Court reserved its verdict on 22 September 2026. The issue had reached a 7-judge Bench through the referral dated 6 October 1999.
Start your journey today
Apply Now*T&C apply